Bull vs bear markets: what happens on-chain when the cycle turns?
The labels describe prices. Underneath, a crypto downturn also shrinks collateral, deposits and yields, and smart contracts react to each one automatically.

On this page
- By the SEC's rule of thumb, a bull or bear market is a broad index climbing or sliding by a fifth or more, sustained for two months or longer.[2][1]
- The ECB said crypto-asset market value fell from €2.5 trillion to under €1 trillion within about a year.[3]
- TVL multiplies deposited tokens by their price, so it falls in a downturn even if nobody withdraws.[4]
- Falling collateral forces leveraged positions to sell, which the BIS says pushes prices down further.[5]
- High advertised yields can vanish in a bust: TerraUSD and LUNA fell close to zero in May 2022.[9]
What do bull and bear mean, briefly?
Investor.gov describes a bull market as rising prices with optimistic sentiment and a bear market as falling prices with pessimistic sentiment, and gives a rule of thumb for both: an index of the wide market gaining or losing at least 20%, sustained for two months or longer.[2][1] The labels are applied after the fact; nobody knows a bear market has begun until the fall has already happened.
The 20% line was built for broad stock indexes. Crypto cycles are much deeper. The ECB's Fabio Panetta said in December 2022 that crypto-asset market value had shrunk from €2.5 trillion at its peak a year earlier to less than €1 trillion, and that bitcoin had fallen more than 70% from its peak.[3] The rest of this page looks at what such a fall does inside the protocols themselves.
Why does total value locked fall faster than deposits?
IOSCO describes total value locked (TVL) as the number of tokens deposited multiplied by their market value, and warns that it changes with that value.[4] A downturn therefore hits TVL twice: once through price and again when depositors leave. IOSCO reports DeFi TVL at about $180 billion in November 2021 and about $47 billion at the end of November 2023,[4] roughly 26% of the peak.
See what is TVL for why the measure can also double-count.[4]
What happens to leveraged positions when prices turn?
DeFi loans are backed by crypto collateral, so a bear market erodes the backing of every open loan at once. On Aave, a position can be liquidated when its health factor falls below 1, and liquidators repay debt in exchange for collateral plus a bonus.[6] The BIS warns that this kind of leverage is procyclical: falling collateral forces sales, which push prices down further.[5] Mechanics in DeFi lending and borrowing.
How do yield promises behave across a cycle?
Yields that look stable in a rising market can depend on conditions that disappear in a falling one. The US Department of Justice says the Anchor protocol advertised about 20% a year on deposits of TerraUSD (UST).[7] When the peg broke in May 2022, UST and its sister tokens fell close to zero and about $40 billion of market value was wiped out, according to the SEC.[9] The DOJ also says an earlier depeg in May 2021 was quietly propped up by a trading firm buying UST,[8] so the bull-market recovery that seemed to prove the design was not what it looked like.
An NBER study of the crash adds a protocol-level detail: because the blockchain is public, investors could watch one another, which sped up the run, and wealthier investors who left first lost less.[10] The full story is in what happened to TerraUSD.
| On-chain measure | How it is built | Why a bear market hits it |
|---|---|---|
| TVL | Tokens deposited × token price[4] | Lower prices and withdrawals compound |
| Loan health factor | Collateral value × threshold ÷ debt[6] | Collateral value falls while debt stays put |
| Advertised yield | Whatever the protocol pays out, from whatever source | A promised rate can vanish with the system behind it, as Anchor's did[7][9] |
What mistakes do people make in crypto bull and bear markets?
- Reading TVL growth as adoption. In a bull market, rising prices alone lift TVL.[4]
- Borrowing against peak prices. Collateral that looks ample at the top can be liquidated in a normal crypto drawdown.[6]
- Trusting a yield because it survived one dip. The DOJ says UST's 2021 recovery was propped up.[8]
- Waiting to see what others do. In the Terra run, later leavers lost more, the NBER study found.[10]
Questions readers ask
Is a 20% drop in one token a bear market?
The SEC guideline is about a whole-market index; one asset on its own is outside it.[1] A 20% swing in one token is therefore not a bear market by that definition.
Does falling TVL mean people are leaving a protocol?
Not necessarily. TVL moves with token prices, so it can fall sharply with no withdrawals at all.[4]
Bull and bear describe price moves of roughly 20% or more.[2][1] On-chain, a bear market is also a stress test: TVL shrinks with prices, leveraged positions are liquidated and yields that depended on rising prices disappear.[4][5]
Go deeper: for how bull and bear markets are defined and what they mean for investors, read more on Investing Unlocked: bull and bear markets.
Sources
- US Securities and Exchange Commission — Investor.gov, Bear market (glossary) (2024)Primary source
- US Securities and Exchange Commission — Investor.gov, Bull market (glossary) (2024)Primary source
- European Central Bank, Crypto dominos: the bursting crypto bubbles and the destiny of digital finance (speech by Fabio Panetta) (2022)Primary source
- International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), Final Report with Policy Recommendations for Decentralized Finance (DeFi) (2023)Primary source
- Bank for International Settlements, DeFi risks and the decentralisation illusion (BIS Quarterly Review, December 2021) (2021)Primary source
- Aave documentation, Health Factor & Liquidations (2025)Primary source
- US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, Do Kwon Pleads Guilty To Fraud (2025)Primary source
- US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York, Crypto-Enabled Fraudster Sentenced For Orchestrating $40 Billion Fraud (2025)Primary source
- US Securities and Exchange Commission, Press release 2024-73: Terraform and Do Kwon settlement following jury verdict (2024)Primary source
- National Bureau of Economic Research, Anatomy of a Run: The Terra Luna Crash (Working Paper 31160) (2023)
Educational content only — not financial, investment, legal or tax advice. Crypto-assets are high-risk and you could lose all the money you put in. Rules differ by country; check with your national regulator. See our risk disclosure and editorial policy.


